Site Meter Cinema Hype » Blog Archive » Heartless: The Incredible Hulk

Heartless: The Incredible Hulk

by Liz

hulk1.jpg

To understand the newest rendition of The Incredible Hulk, you’d have to go back a few years. Not to 1962, when Stan Lee first premiered the character, but to 2003, when Ang Lee tried to bring him to the big screen and ended up with one of the biggest superhero-movie bombs in cinematic history. The Lee Hulk is long. It’s a thinker. It’s the worst thing a superhero movie can be: it’s boring. The Marvel Entertainment Hulk reboot, which opens today nationwide, is a clear reaction to the previous film—almost a point-by-point rebuttal—and it seems to accomplish the goal of amping up the Hulk franchise once again. However, if the further target is to create another thoughtful superhero film within the Marvel universe, something’s gone seriously off-course.

The Incredible Hulk’s success as an action flick is a relief, but it’s not surprising. Director Louis Leterrier keeps things speedy and simple, with a standard three action sequences—big, bigger, biggest—and a running time of less than two hours. It’s not very original, and it feels basic, but it works anyway; if anything, the Hulk-vs.-everybody-else scenes feel like a blend of modern CGI with a classic, pre-Michael-Bay eye for crafting complete stories within the action, without the nausea- and confusion-inducing close cuts we see in other action movies. Leterrier functions on a scale that’s appropriate for the Hulk, including plenty of story in his biggest, most elaborate sequences. Audiences looking for a good summer action movie should be pleased.

So the problem with The Incredible Hulk isn’t with the Hulk. The Hulk’s fine. Great, even. He does his crashing-around rage thing. But his poor alter ego, physicist Bruce Banner, gets short shrift, and the movie suffers because of it. Bruce’s backstory comes out in a vague kind of way during the opening credits—there’s a montage—and after that, nothing. We know how he feels about his girlfriend, Betty Ross, but then we know how most men would feel if they were dating a brilliant biologist in Liv Tyler’s body. Whether it’s a reaction to the overwrought backstory in Lee’s Hulk, this Bruce Banner never makes it into the third dimension. And what is a superhero without his or her alter ego? A superhero who’s only a superhero misses the point, doesn’t tell us anything about ourselves, and becomes vaguely resentable. Maybe nobody’s actively disliking Bruce Banner, but it’s difficult to connect with a character who won’t show his cards. It’s a shame, really. Why go to the trouble of hiring Edward Norton—arguably one of the best actors working onscreen today—and then give him so little to do? Norton’s a great choice for Bruce Banner; his regular-Joe looks and slight build make him a natural counterpoint to the alter ego he hates so much, and he’s the kind of actor who could easily lend added depth to a shallowly-written role. All he needs is a good line or two. Maybe a pensive look. We want to know this guy, and the movie never gets us there.

In the end, this reboot will probably be marked down as a success. Fans can heal from their disappointment over the Lee adaptation; it’ll do well at the box office; Marvel will keep up its winning streak, and maybe stretch it into a Hulk sequel. There’s plenty to enjoy here, in a spectacular, smash-and-grab kind of way. But if a contribution to the canon of complex, well-rounded superhero movies was Marvel’s intent, they seem to have overshot.

, , , , , ,

Did You Enjoy this Post? Subscribe to Cinema Hype. It's Free!

2 Responses to “Heartless: The Incredible Hulk

  1. incredible hulk | Hottags Says:

    [...] Heartless: The Incredible HulkTo understand the newest rendition of The Incredible Hulk, you’d have to go back a few years. Not to 1962, when Stan Lee first premiered the character, but to 2003, when Ang Lee tried to bring him to the big screen and ended up with one …Cinema Hype - http://www.cinemahype.com [...]

  2. Review: Incredible Hulk Is A Handsome Hunk Of Mayhem | QuickNews Says:

    [...] http://www.cinemahype.com [...]

Leave a Reply


About Cinema Hype

A blog about all things film: the good, the bad, and the really, really ugly. Check us out for news, reviews, haikus, and also other things that don't rhyme, like movie quotations, polls, and commentary. And we won't throw popcorn at you or kick your seat.

Cinema Hype Author(s)
    » Liz

Entertainment & Music Channel Posts

  • Movie Review - "Public Enemies"
    ** STARS In the action-thriller "Public Enemies", acclaimed filmmaker Michael Mann directs Johnny Depp, Christian Bale and Best Actress Academy Award winner Marion Cotillard in the story of [...]
  • Music Video Flashbacks: Early 80's Pop Songs
    REAL LIFE - "SEND ME AN ANGEL (1983)" MEN WITHOUT HATS - "SAFETY DANCE" (1983) FLOCK OF SEAGULLS - "I RAN (SO FAR AWAY)" (1982) THE THOMPSON TWINS - "HOLD ME NOW" (1983) [...]
  • Reunion Time In America
    It's high-school reunion time throughout America and, wherever you're having yours, you know the routine: It usually starts with an advance notice, which then builds curiosity. Then, as the day [...]
  • Goodbye, Mrs. Slocombe
    She was one of the most recognizable faces on television -- and "I am unanimous in that." Mollie Sugden, who played Mrs. Slocombe on the famous UK comedy series, Are You Being Served?, passed away [...]
  • Free Streaming Jukebox: 25 New Summer Songs by Rob Thomas, Basement Jaxx, U2, The Pussycat Dolls & MORE!!
    LISTEN TO A FRESH MIX OF 25 NEW SONGS FOR SUMMER 2009!! THIS IS A GREAT JUKEBOX TO LISTEN TO WHEN CLEANING HOUSE, SURFING THE NET, HANGING OUT WITH FRIENDS OR KILLING TIME AT WORK. CLICK [...]
  • Hayao Miyazaki & Walt Disney Animation's "Ponyo" Movie Trailer
    "Ponyo" (titled "Ponyo on the Cliff by the Sea" in it's native Japan when it was release in 2008) is a 2009 animated film by the Japanese anime studio Studio Ghibli, written and directed by Hayao [...]
  • How NOT To Make It (for long)
    Y'know, we've talked a lot about how to start a rock band, get its first gigs and into the ears of those who can help move it forward. But there's one thing that every band should do ... and [...]
  • The Bacon Effect
    If you haven't heard this duo, you're really missing ... wait a minnit ... isn't ... isn't one of them ...??? Yep!  It's actor/writer/guitarist/singer Kevin Bacon (uh-huh ... he of famed loose [...]
  • Michael's Earth Song
    If there's any video that Michael Jackson left us that we actually NEED to watch, I believe it's to his Earth Song (from his HISTORY CD). Man, see if this doesn't hit ya right in the [...]
  • Def Leppard Day and the Sky
    Hey ... you can celebrate 'Def Leppard Day' today … if you’re in Hamburg, New York, anyway. The town board voted unanimously this past Monday to officially designate the day to honor one of [...]

Hot Off The Press

  • Out Of Key T-Shirt
    Whacked. Not like, "This shirt is whack." Whacked like Tony Soprano whacked. $17 Buy [...]
  • Video Taping a Show
    This is not allowed. This is not a legal thing to do. That being said, you need to get video footage of yourself performing. What does that mean? You have to do something illegal. It's a double-edged [...]
  • Interviews are going up!
    At long last! We have interviews going up at CBS2! So check it out here, as Diane interviews. It's hard to hear Diane, as usual, so up your volume a bit! (I'm sure someone will youtube them too - [...]
  • Michael Jackson Memorial
    You know, it’s hard to say what I really think but for the most part, I feel like the man has died and as long as the family is willing to share a memorial for their family member, then this is an [...]
  • Is their Relief when Eating Healthy?
    There comes a huge sense of relief when I am eating natural foods like fruits and vegetables. I don't question what I am putting into my body because it is all natural. If I had the money, I would [...]
  • New Spin Cycle: Sting, Jeff Jarrett, Jim Cornette, Don West
    JB is back with the latest edition of "TNA Spin Cycle", featuring Sting, Jeff Jarrett, Jim Cornette and Don West. [...]
  • Little things
    There are a lot of things that suck about being a part time dad. Not having him here all the time. Going half days on holidays and birthdays. The big stuff that you think about when seperated parents [...]
  • 4TH OF JULY REMEMBRANCES
    Tomorrow is the Fourth of July, Independance Day here in the U.S., and I thought it only appropriate to spend a few minutes thinking about the price paid for our "freedom". Have you ever [...]
  • Clip of the Week
    This week's clip comes from Guiding Light. It is a clip from the Bauer BBQ of Danny and Michelle getting married. [...]
  • Bacon Heart T-Shirt
    Show the world your unhealthy love for the good stuff with this Bacon Heart T-Shirt from bustedtees. America's national meat deserves a shirt like this. And so do you. Check out RetailMeNot.com [...]